WEBVTT

00:01.859 --> 00:27.203
I'm Jason from Smoking and Drinking in Space, a sci-fi podcast from a couple guys who think they know sci-fi. And I'm Rob from Smoking and Drinking in Capes, a superhero podcast from a couple guys who wish they had powers. And we're part of the Gunna Geek Network, just like the show you're checking out now. Shows on the network are individually owned and opinions expressed may not reflect others. And you can find other cool, awesome, geeky shows at gunnageeknetwork.com.

00:33.759 --> 00:36.356
Art, comedy, pop culture, and much more.

00:36.725 --> 01:35.485
You're listening to ACPN. And welcome to PlayComics, where once again we're looking at a video game based on a comic property and how well it represents that source material. And today I am here with Chris Maynard. Because we're looking at Garfield and that might be the nicest thing we're going to say the entire time.

01:35.485 --> 01:44.490
Yeah, I won't— we haven't talked about this ahead of time, but yes, I would agree with that sentiment. That's probably about as nice as it's going to get.

01:44.490 --> 01:54.040
So Chris, just setting the table on things, really, what is it that made you look at the list of games that I'm looking for right now and say, ooh, look, Garfield, I want to do that?

01:54.040 --> 02:24.772
I guess it's a level of self-hatred that I have where I would see that and say, I knew what I was getting in, um, getting in for when I was looking at this one. Uh, movie adaptations of video games are generally not great. The only thing worse is when you have a video game adaptation of a movie. Um, those are notoriously bad, and I've never dipped my toes in these waters, so I figured why not give it a shot and see if I might find a pleasant surprise. And I did not find a pleasant surprise with this one.

02:24.772 --> 02:34.047
Well, um, there are things where you will find a pleasant surprise. It is definitely not this one. What is it that got you into Garfield in the first place?

02:34.047 --> 04:01.220
So Garfield's been one of those characters that's always been around ever since I was a kid. I read the comic strips. I'm 49. So back when we used to actually get newspapers delivered to the house, I would read the Garfield comic strip. I think there was— there's been several iterations of the cartoon. Specifically, there was one that was on when I was about 6 or 7, I would say, that I was watching. It was on at the same time as a lesser than, but was my preferred, uh, character, which was Heathcliff, which was kind of a wannabe Garfield to some degree. And so it's just been one of those things that's always been around. And then the movies were always this strange thing because somehow they had Bill Murray as Garfield, which just never made sense. And it's always been this sort of cultural object that I've been kind of fascinated with because it's never made sense to me. So they're not the best movies. They're not terrible movies to me personally. They're not made for me though. I fully recognize that this is made for a 6-year-old. And when I have, when I had 6-year-olds and I would take them to see these movies, they loved them. So I can watch them through my kids' eyes at the time when they were coming out and enjoy them. When you go back and watch it through a critical eye as an adult, they don't really hold up very well, but they're not also supposed to. And that's okay. Not everything needs to be a Pixar movie that, you know, breaks the heart of an adult. You can have ones that are just Absolutely designed for a kid. And I kind of love that about these films. They are unabashedly not made for me. And I like that.

04:01.220 --> 04:45.035
That is one thing I really appreciate. Garfield, everybody working on Garfield knows what they're doing. They know who their audience is. They're making this for their audience. So yeah, you know, we're going to get our old person has to sit through the movie with their kids little moments of, all right, cool. Here's a joke that's definitely for us and not for the kids. And that's okay. They're not for us though, like you said. So I mean, me, I feel like sometimes I never grew up because I keep watching kids' cartoons and even ones that I didn't grow up on, I've gone back and watched those and everything. And I'm assuming that you were also watching Garfield and Friends because that is just, that is probably the best Garfield cartoon that they will ever make.

04:45.035 --> 05:19.366
Oh yeah. Yeah. That, that was definitely the one that I was watching and It's, it's strange because I don't go back to this particular series very often. Um, but while it is designed completely for kids, it is something that has like this design that was in the comic strip where there's something left over where I think there was this kind of Mondays suck attitude towards that Garfield always had that, you know, I didn't necessarily get as a kid. There was, he was a cranky old man and I'm not sure why that character was appealing to children, but it is something that when you're a kid, I think you can lock into for some reason.

05:19.366 --> 06:00.423
The only thing I can think of is that as a kid, there are things that you think just suck and it doesn't matter. It can be homework sucks, cleaning my room sucks, you know, taking out the garbage sucks. Garfield's thing is just Mondays. And I never really understood why he cared so much about Mondays in particular. Like in the general sense of the real world, yeah, you know, you're coming off the weekend, you have to go back to work. But for Garfield, He's a cat. He doesn't have to go back to work. And Jon is a cartoonist, so he doesn't necessarily work like a normal Monday to Friday, 9 to 5. And I'm assuming he's also working from his house. So even if he's at work, he can still play with Garfield.

06:00.423 --> 06:49.356
Yeah, it's, uh, I'm not sure what the hangup is for him. There's not a lot that, uh, he has to do. There's not a huge difference between Sunday and Monday for this particular character. So, but I think that energy is something you're right that a kid can appreciate. Because when I was young and even as young as first grade, I can remember living in the Northeast and there was the chance that you might miss a day for a snow day or something like that. And that was the most exciting night of the year when you might actually miss a day of school. And on Sunday night, it wasn't so much as like the Sunday scaries where you're dreading. For me personally, I wasn't dreading going to school on Monday, but I wouldn't say I was looking forward to it. So I guess maybe that's where the entry point would be. Yeah, yeah, he gets it. He knows what it's like to not want to wake up on Monday morning.

06:49.356 --> 07:10.600
As for the whole Bill Murray of it all, I have to think that this was just tied to some other project he wanted to do, and him getting sucked into these was what allowed him to do those other projects. I have no information to back that up at all. I can't point to anything. I think that what those projects would have been, but I mean, how else do you get Bill Murray into a Garfield movie like these are?

07:10.600 --> 07:56.543
I don't know, because it's— he notoriously has an unusual process for how he picks projects, where I'm pretty sure to this day he just has an answering machine that people leave messages on, and then he listens to pitches through that. And if something comes across his desk or across his machine that he's interested in, he follows up on it. Just a number you call. And I don't know why he chose to do Garfield unless it was a cynical kind of thing where he got paid a very nice salary. salary for, or if it was something where he was mistaken. I have no clue why he would take this material on, but it does feel like he— it doesn't feel cynical in his performance. It does feel like he genuinely enjoys the work that he's doing. I don't get it, but it seems like he's having a good time in the performance always.

07:56.543 --> 07:58.304
Maybe he just is Garfield.

07:58.304 --> 08:11.169
Yeah, yeah, there is— his persona does line out, I think, a little bit with what the character is. So there's definitely that Venn diagram. There's a little bit of overlap.

08:11.169 --> 08:16.255
And this game that we're looking at, it is based specifically on the Garfield movie, A Tale of Two Kitties.

08:16.255 --> 08:17.506
Right.

08:17.506 --> 08:24.083
The movie exists. I don't even— but like we said, it's made for 6-year-olds. So yeah, you know, take it as you will.

08:24.083 --> 08:27.212
Did you go back and rewatch the movie for this episode?

08:27.212 --> 08:53.146
I was a horrible person and didn't just because the past few days have completely gotten away from me. It's part of the dangers of my process is I go and I try to watch these movies like in a day or two beforehand, and the past few days have just kind of exploded in all kinds of weird ways. So I ended up having to just watch some reviews and read some stuff about it. And what are you going to do? It's a Garfield movie made for 6-year-olds.

08:53.146 --> 08:58.496
What did the, uh, what was the general takeaway? Because I did watch the movie last night, actually.

08:58.496 --> 09:04.320
The general thing I was picking up on was a lot of Why does this exist?

09:04.320 --> 10:05.447
Yeah, fair enough. I mean, I don't know that kids' movies need to justify their existence in that sense. I live in Arizona, so it's an hour and a half where you can take a child into a dark, cold room and they can enjoy themselves for a little bit. And it's a respite from the day. That's why this exists. And watching it last night, it's not a good movie. There's a lot worse movies out there, though. This isn't an offensive film. It's not something that's so terrible that it's what went wrong here. It's just a, yeah, it's exactly what you would expect it to be. If you have any other expectations, I don't know what film you were trying to watch. And putting it through the critical lens, to me, it's most important is the intent of the filmmaker. Did they make the movie they were trying to make? Does it feel like they got across what they wanted to do? Does feel like they were successful in making the movie they wanted to. I could absolutely imagine a kid enjoying this. Just, it's a silly movie and it's okay to have silly movies. There's nothing wrong with that.

10:05.447 --> 10:42.107
I think that is a trap that this one is really falling into because we're wanting everything to be some profound statement these days and stuff. And this movie is just definitely not that. It is a Garfield movie where Garfield does Garfield things and Jon and Liz and everybody else do their things and there's no surprises in it. There's nothing really like there's no major takeaway from it, but it's fun for what it is. So, and honestly, I think it's some, any real critical eye you put on this is putting way too critical of an eye on it because it's not meant to be that at all.

10:42.107 --> 11:28.442
Yeah. There's certain films that are critic-proof and this is one of them where it just, it doesn't matter. You know, if you're putting it through that lens and thinking about it that way, it wasn't designed for that. It's similar complaint with the Mario movies. where you hear that it's just bright colors and a lot of like key jangling, which is fine. It doesn't need to be anything more than that. And there's a lot of people that are entertained by it. The Minions movies are the same way. There's things that just are not designed for you. Um, I, that's okay. Cause I have The Iron Giant. I have these other movies that I can go to and I can watch that do really hit me, but I don't necessarily want to watch a film with, you know, when I, my kids are a little bit older now, but sitting down with my 10-year-old and the idea of watching a movie that's going to make us both cry. I don't know, sometimes, but that's not what I want out of every time we go to the theater.

11:28.442 --> 11:54.970
And what else I think is weird about the whole aspect of it is if you're somebody who is a giant Garfield fan, then you're probably not going to have a problem with this movie. Just like if you're somebody who is a giant Transformers fan, you're not going to have a problem. Actually, I probably triggered a whole bunch of people from the whole Michael Bay of it all. But if you go back to the old animated movies, if you're a giant Transformers fan, you're not going to have— no, that's the worst example because they killed everybody. What are we going to do here?

11:55.080 --> 11:59.280
They did. But I mean, the general point stands. Orson Welles randomly in that movie.

11:59.280 --> 12:19.020
I know. The general point stands though. Like, if you're a giant fan of the franchise, you're going to like that it exists. You're going to like that you get to see the characters and everything. So if you're watching this and you're not already a giant fan of Garfield, then if you like don't have a kid that you're watching it with, I don't understand why you're watching it in the first place.

12:19.020 --> 12:41.490
Unless you have it as an assignment for a podcast. Those are the 2 excuses that you have. Either that. You did that to yourself. I did do that to my— well, I looked at the list and this is the one that felt like it could be the most fun conversation. So that's why I chose it more than anything. Not that I really wanted to spend any more time in this world. So I was willing to jump on that grenade for this one.

12:41.490 --> 13:12.253
Well, with that, we're going to go throw some lasagna in the oven while I drop some promos for a few other shows. Are you looking for an actual play podcast with young, hot roleplayers, disciplined professional voice actors, and wholesome content? Well, this isn't that podcast! AARPGeek is an adults-only podcast with interviews, actual play stories where—

13:12.253 --> 13:16.267
Uh, excuse me, Matt, why do you sound like you've been chain smoking since you were a toddler?

13:16.267 --> 13:18.406
What do you mean? Uh, the voice.

13:18.502 --> 13:40.085
You don't have to do that voice, man. I don't? Nah, just tell them that we're a group of old friends who like to get together, hang out, play lots of different types of games, and we want them to feel like they're sitting at the table with us. And they can find us just by searching for The AARPG Podcast on their favorite podcatcher and @TheAARPGs on YouTube.

13:43.686 --> 14:58.833
It is critical you pay attention at this time. Ready to blast off into Marvel's NovaVerse? Join Xandar Radio, a Nova podcast, your ultimate destination for everything Nova. I'm Doug Smith, producer and co-host of Xandar Radio. We bring you news, deep dive reviews, fan spotlights, creator interviews, and epic roundtable discussions. Whether you're a diehard fan of Annihilation, The New Warriors, or love the various Nova runs, this is your show. So grab your Nova helmet, power up, and tune in at novaprimepage.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Xandar Radio, because the Nova Corps needs you. Those are some great things to check out, but first let's finish up here. So Chris, what is really bringing us together today is this game that came out in 2006, Garfield: A Tale of Two Kitties. For as far as we care on this show, it came out on the DS and the PS2, made by Two Tribes or Asobo Studio based on which console you're playing it on. Either way, it was published by The Game Factory and it's basically play the movie except in mini games.

14:58.833 --> 15:01.707
Did you, which version of this did you play?

15:01.707 --> 15:04.067
I was looking more at the DS version.

15:04.757 --> 15:50.657
Okay. Because I played the PC version of this, which is wildly different. These are 2, apparently I found this out last night because I don't have a DS anymore. And so I played the PC version of it that they had. And it was, it seems like they were different games completely where the version that I played was closer to a, it felt like a ripoff of Mario Galaxy. And so it was like a 3D game and there's a lot of spinning where you had this move where you'd spin your tail to kill rats and stuff like that. So it felt very much like the move that you would do in that game where you would spin around with your hat. And so it was kind of a knockoff of that. What was the game like that you played? Because it was so different. I'm sorry, we're on different pages here where I watched the movie, you didn't watch the movie, and we played 2 different iterations of the game.

15:50.657 --> 16:17.337
And that's part of the fun of doing the show though, isn't it? Is you've got these things that are put out with such different viewpoints. I mean, the DS version is, I mean, it's still basically the DS version of Play the movie. Like everything's kind of dumbed down for the DS. So you change up what some of the levels are. You change up what some of the mini game things in there are, but essentially you've got the same basic idea. You got the same ingredients and you made a different dish.

16:17.337 --> 16:27.503
Okay. Fair enough. You know, but you, sometimes those same ingredients can be wildly different though. You know, you end up with a piece of pizza versus a calzone. Those are different experiences.

16:27.503 --> 16:38.213
Definitely. And I think these, this is even more different than that example would be. And from me looking at everything, it looks like the PS2 version is a lot closer to the PC version that you played.

16:38.213 --> 17:13.359
Okay. All right. Yeah. And it was one of those games that of this era, one of the reasons that I have a tough time in going back to these games, the gameplay is fine, but the cutscenes that they were so in love with at this time period are very long and they are not very good. And so there's a surprising amount of cutscenes that you have during the tutorial. piece of this where you just start playing and it's teaching you how to play the game. And it's probably a good 20 minutes of the maybe 2 to 3 hours of total gameplay that you get to get through the game is tutorial, which seems like a lot.

17:13.359 --> 17:16.988
Wait, are you saying in 2006 they still didn't have good voice acting?

17:16.988 --> 17:32.642
Well, that's not exactly what I was saying with that, but yeah, yes, absolutely. I mean, I would, I'll put it on par with what I heard in Mandalorian and Grogu as far as bad voice acting in a game. So yeah, there you go. We still have bad voice acting to this day.

17:32.642 --> 17:55.317
Yeah. I mean, the cutscenes throughout this entire game, they've got that weird PS2, let's make things realistic, which just hasn't aged too well. It's a little easier for me, and I'm assuming you as well, to look at those and give them a bit of slack because we were there when those were the new thing. And my dad legitimately would see my brother and I playing sports games and think we were watching a game on TV.

17:55.317 --> 17:56.778
Yeah, I remember that.

17:56.778 --> 18:03.165
Which I look at that now and I don't understand it at all. But, you know, back then, okay, cool. It's just a pixelated camera or something somehow.

18:03.165 --> 18:34.853
But it's this particular era of games has probably aged the worst. Because if you go back the generation just before this, or I guess it would be 2 before, if you're looking at like NES games, N64 games, all those, they have a charm to them. But there's a point where they push it just a little bit further than the N64 when you get past the GoldenEye era. And it just, they're trying to make it photorealistic and they lose the cartoonishness. And when you stick with the cartoonish side of this, it's just more fun. And those graphics to me and that gameplay actually holds up pretty well.

18:34.853 --> 18:49.056
I think PS1 is the perfect console to look at that dichotomy because you have a bunch of games where they knew they couldn't make it really photorealistic, so they didn't try. And then you have other games where they did try to make it photorealistic. And I mean, it looks good. It's a 32-bit console.

18:49.056 --> 18:49.522
Yeah.

18:49.522 --> 18:51.868
But we're looking at it now comparing it to a PS5.

18:51.868 --> 19:27.731
Yeah. It's so wildly different. The thing that kills me when I play PS1 games now, it's honestly, it's the load time. So the original gameplay on something like Resident Evil, I actually find the playing of that game to be really fun still. But the load time in between the jump scares and things like that, it's just very— we got spoiled basically. And it's hard to imagine that I thought that this was so intense at the time and that I would get so wrapped up in the gameplay. But yeah, it's— I like going back and playing old console games from years ago, just to see how much further we are along in such a short period of time, really.

19:27.731 --> 19:46.632
And realistic in the sense of this game, you're really only trying to get it to be realistic to what the movie was looking like. So you already had a Garfield in the movie that wasn't looking too realistic anyway. So in that sense, the game captured him really well because they had about the same level of technology available to do it.

19:46.632 --> 20:51.425
Yeah, it's, uh, the photorealism that they go for in the film, it's heightened. And so, yeah, it's not— I don't think it ever convinced anyone at the time. So, but it is something that when I look at the computer animation in the film, it's not distracting because it has a style that it's going for. If it was, I don't know, it's just cartoonish enough that it feels intentional. So it would be, but it's just that thing where you have Garfield, that character next to a live-action Odie, which is a really interesting choice that they go for. All the other animals in it. are played by actual animals. And then you have the one character of Garfield that is animated, which I think it's a stylistic choice that I genuinely appreciate. And it makes it so that you, to me personally, I let go of the quality of animation because it feels like it is a choice that they're going for. That it'd say, look, this by design looks different than everybody else because this is a character that is different than the rest of the animals that it interacts with. Except for in A Tale of Two Kitties, the two Garfields are one and the same, which makes sense.

20:51.425 --> 20:59.569
I do appreciate that they actually had Odie in here. Odie is possibly a favorite just because of all of the never-ending optimism.

20:59.569 --> 21:07.087
Is Odie the first example of toxic positivity that we had as a child?

21:07.087 --> 21:28.538
It really could be because I can't think of anything earlier than that. And I mean, granted, Garfield was well established by the time I was born. and conscious enough to be reading the comics anyway. But I can't think of anything older than that really that would be just, I'm going to love you no matter what, no matter how horrible you treat me, I'm still going to love you.

21:28.538 --> 21:57.549
Yeah, this is a— if you put it through that lens and you think of this as a relationship that they're in, this is a bad relationship that really Odie needs to walk away from. He needs to be done with this. Odie needs to be able to stand up for himself, that he is not being treated well by Garfield. And I genuinely Even as a kid, I think that you have sympathy. That's your entry point for the series is that you love this goofball. And so, yeah, but it's fun to watch their interplay.

21:57.549 --> 22:08.364
And it's nice seeing Garfield interact with all the other animals there, you know, the animals in the castle and everything trying to get him into the world. It's a cool aspect of all of it.

22:08.364 --> 22:18.752
So overall, what do you think of the gameplay in it? And is this something that If you weren't doing this for this show, is this something that you'll ever pick up again? I guess would be a good test of it.

22:18.752 --> 22:32.035
Probably not ever again. Because I can get the same endorphins that I would get playing this from games that I will enjoy more. I mean, it's a game made for little kids based on a movie made for little kids.

22:32.035 --> 23:26.083
Yeah, very true. You know, that's a good way to look at it because it was the PC version of it. Like I was saying, it's very similar to, you know, Mario 64 or Galaxy. And so when it has that feeling, it just makes you want to go play that game and drop what you're doing right now when it feels— so there's other games that it can make you feel like. But if you're thinking of that as a gateway game in this, you know, same way you have like a gateway horror film, you know, this is a good gateway game for a kid that you could put, you could hand this, put this in the hands of a 5-year-old and they would get it. They would be able to play and have a good time. And I think that that, great for that because the other games might be a little bit too advanced for them. So yeah, it's a good entry point for that. And I guess in the same way that the cartoon is a good entry point for sort of the odd couple type comedy, that, you know, this is a good entry point in the game as well. So for a young child, not for a couple of middle-aged guys, probably.

23:26.083 --> 23:31.323
Keeping all of that in mind, what do you think this game really gets right looking at Garfield?

23:31.756 --> 24:43.126
So to me, a good adaptation going either direction captures what it feels like to engage with the source material. So if it's an adaptation of a book, you want it to not go beat by beat and adapt all the moments that you really loved, but capture the feeling of it is more important to me. I think a lot of video game adaptations, that's where they get it wrong, where they try to capture the plot point by point, and then they lose what it felt like to actually engage with it. And so with this, there's that— the garden piece of this, it does have that chaotic part of the film that I think kids would really like, where he's just running around breaking stuff. And so there is an element of Grand Theft Auto for kids for this, where you just go into the house and you, you know, you smash the vases, the vases, things like that. So I think that it does work. work in that sense as far as capturing what it was like. As long as you, again, think of this through the lens of who it's designed for, I think it works. I think it does capture the emotion of it. And to me, that's what marks a good adaptation. What do you think makes a good adaptation of a video game, or what makes a good video game adaptation of another property?

24:43.126 --> 25:39.156
This one, I think, really hits all of the high points of Garfield. You have Garfield, he wants to get his own way. Because he is a selfish narcissistic cat, which is probably a little bit redundant there because he is a cat. But you go in there and Garfield does have these adventures. Everything centers on him. He is the most important person in the room, no matter where he is, no matter who else is in there. And this does kind of capture the Garfield, you know, self-idolization of everything. And that's one thing that I really appreciate when you go in there, when they say, okay, here's your character. You get to be the character. You get to feel like the character. Like in the past, as far as recording goes, but the future as far as release goes, which might be the past for release because I don't know how things are going to come out yet. You know, there's a Spider-Man game that I looked at where you don't really get to swing on your webs and there's no good reason for it.

25:39.156 --> 25:39.669
Oh.

25:39.669 --> 25:48.871
So it's weird. If you're looking at the Ultimate Spider-Man game, then you can't swing on your webs if you're in the park, but there's nothing for him to swing from. So it makes sense in the world.

25:48.871 --> 25:49.385
Sure.

25:49.385 --> 26:03.636
You know, so in this one, basically all of the aspects of Garfield are there. You have him just eating food that he finds randomly lying around because he loves lasagna. Why is it weird that there's lasagna just waiting around? It's obviously for him.

26:03.636 --> 26:04.809
Yeah.

26:04.809 --> 26:11.742
You have everybody trying to get him to do things, but he does it because he wants to and it's going to benefit him.

26:11.742 --> 27:30.368
I think that's a great call out because if you— if they made him into too much of a hero in it, then that wouldn't ring true to the story itself. And you're right, I think that that is one of the strengths of this, that it does play into his narcissistic tendencies, that it is really about him getting what he wants and he's just accidentally helping people along the way, which very much feels in line with the Original comic strip and with the, uh, with the film, the films that they're coming from with this. Um, this works interestingly though as an adaptation of an adaptation of an adaptation. So you're kind of like getting through a point where you would take a VHS camera, uh, camcorder and point it at the TV screen and it would just kind of go on an infinite loop because you're looking at A Tale of Two Cities that's adapted into this film, this framework for this movie, then it is adapted into a video game and then not adapted into yet another video game. Now, I'll give you that Tale of Two Cities is a story that is ripe for reinterpretation, and clearly we do it over and over and over again, like every 5 years or so. But I didn't feel like the Garfield movie was something that necessarily would spawn multiple adaptations of it. To see that they took different approaches with all these games is kind of— it amused me, honestly, that there was They felt the need to put so much into this. It's kind of surprising.

27:30.368 --> 27:39.864
On the other hand, if you just need to put out a franchise movie like this, there's worse things you can do than grabbing classic literature and just saying, okay, it's a Garfield story now.

27:39.864 --> 28:03.992
Yeah. But to me, does that feel like something you do, like with the 4th film or even the 5th film, that they immediately jump to, okay, we have to put them in Europe. We have to do all that. We have to pull them out of fish out of water. We have to really change this. It feels like something that you kind of do a little bit further along in the franchise than right out of the gate. You're almost putting him in space. Normally you do that by episode 10 or so.

28:03.992 --> 28:11.501
Yeah. There are definitely better choices I think they could have made if they were going to pull classic literature. You could have done—

28:11.501 --> 28:14.117
What would you choose? Just out of curiosity, what would you do?

28:14.117 --> 28:17.454
That's the fun part. I mean, you could have done Don Quixote easily.

28:17.454 --> 28:26.648
Oh, the dynamic works actually with the two of them. I could actually see that. That makes sense with him and Odie just leaning into the windmill. So I get that.

28:26.648 --> 28:35.071
Especially when you get the aspect of Odie could come along and just kind of save the day, but Garfield doesn't realize it. And Odie keeps having to save his butt.

28:35.119 --> 28:35.312
Yeah.

28:35.681 --> 28:46.205
You know, it works. You know, you could have maybe done a Man in the Iron Mask type thing. Garfield gets blamed for something and then he has to come out and prove that it wasn't him.

28:46.205 --> 29:18.558
You know, that, that would actually work. as well. You could do Three Musketeers. Lord of the Flies would work with these 2 characters. Yeah, you could just go through a whole— I guess that's almost the series of Dog Man books though at this point where they intentionally only know this as a dad, but where they would take classic literature. And they had— I think they did— I can't remember what they— they had a version of A Tale of Two Cities also in Dog Man where they had that name. It may have been A Tale of Two Kitties. for that one as well. I can't remember, but it's something very similar to that with the Dogman books.

29:18.558 --> 29:31.131
My wife teaches some, like, that about that age kids. So honestly surprised I haven't heard anything about that specific, like, I know about Dogman on a very basic level. I'm surprised she didn't tell me about this kind of thing though.

29:31.131 --> 30:53.160
They do. It's, it's a consistent thing. I can't, I'm spacing on the names of titles because it's been 5 years since we've had those books in the house. But yeah, they would have these titles for things where it would be a play on some piece of classic literature and it would be a similar story in the same way that this is very loosely an adaptation of something that you could say it was inspired by or they stole the framework for it, which is one of those things that seems like an easier way to get a screenplay off the ground because you just kind of, okay, we have the framework we can work with, but then what do we do within that framework? But those limitations can also hinder you. And so you've backed yourself into this box with the story, which might not be the best thing for the actual material or for the characters going forward. So yeah, I just, I am curious though, for people that are going into this clean for the first time, if they would still enjoy this, if 5-year-olds of today have already been spoiled for a movie like this, or was this very much of a moment where If you have a 5-year-old that's seen Moana and the level of, you know, artistry they see in that, if they've seen the Pixar films, if they've seen Big Hero 6 or whatever it is, you know, name your Disney Pixar movie, would they still be open to this? Because like I show my kids, or I showed them Ray Harryhausen movies when they were very young. And if you don't get them at the exact right moment, they won't watch Jason and the Argonauts because it looks too silly for them.

30:53.160 --> 30:56.869
But it's stupid, silly fun. And that's the whole point.

30:57.046 --> 31:46.624
Exactly. Yeah. But now kids see that and it just doesn't look good to their eyes though. Stop motion animation. I have a big, big old soft spot in my heart for it because to me, Clash of the Titans was a formative film, the original one. And so that those special effects, nothing ever got as cool as that. For them, it's something different and that's okay. The toys of my youth do not need to be the toys of the next generation, which I think we're seeing this weekend where when they keep trying to do that, it doesn't work. And so now we have another iteration of He-Man and the audiences in the world and the, you know, people that are buying tickets keep telling studios, no, we're not interested. No, thank you. Onto the next thing. But they keep doing it over and over and over again. They keep trying to suck any blood or life that they can out of these IPs just because every once in a while you land on a Barbie. And I guess that makes it worthwhile.

31:46.624 --> 31:53.371
I feel like we've probably hit a bunch of these points already, but what do you think this game gets What does it get wrong looking at Garfield?

31:53.371 --> 32:22.964
That's a good question. So if I'm thinking about what it gets wrong about it, it's really the structure of the story being a little bit slavish to it, that if it was a little bit more of an open world and kind of a choose your own adventure aspect instead of having the guardrails so firmly around it. I know there's limitations to what you could do with the game at the time, but if it had a little bit more of that anarchic feeling to it, I think that that would Maybe be a little bit truer to the spirit of the source material.

32:23.637 --> 32:24.166
Probably.

32:25.159 --> 32:57.390
The gameplay is obviously not, again, I can make an excuse for it. Not for me, it's for a kid. So the gameplay is not, I get it. You're able to figure it out pretty quickly and it just takes a little bit too long to get the game going. Then once it gets going, the actual missions or levels as they were are, even me, someone who's only beat a handful of games in my lifetime, that I'm just, Going through this with a little bit of ease. It's kind of like you feel really great when you put together a 10-year-old's jigsaw puzzle, but at the end of the day, you know, it wasn't really designed for you and it should have— if it wasn't super easy, then you have bigger problems.

32:57.631 --> 33:18.179
Yeah. For all of the criticism we've thrown at this, as far as representing Garfield, it doesn't really do anything egregiously wrong. You know, there's other characters they could have put in here, but that also wouldn't have made sense with the story. So I'm glad that they didn't try to shoehorn everybody in here. I mean, it's really hard for me to think of anything that's wrong besides I wish I would've seen this thing.

33:18.179 --> 33:26.000
So then just for your process, how do you land on these things that you're deciding to cover for the show?

33:26.000 --> 33:44.535
I have found a giant list of everything, every game that has been made that is based on a comic. So if it exists and it came out over here in North America, doing it. Which to my detriment in some cases, because there's 5 billion Yu-Gi-Oh games that all came out at once.

33:44.535 --> 33:50.140
Is your goal then to get through all of these, or are you cherry-picking the ones that actually interest you?

33:50.140 --> 33:52.629
I'm going— I'm attempting to do all of them.

33:52.629 --> 34:03.679
Wow. Are they still coming out at the same clip that they used to? Because this used to be a standard of games, and I don't— I feel like I don't see them as often, but I might just be missing it because I'm not as dialed into gaming as I once was.

34:04.579 --> 34:33.385
They seem to have slowed down a lot more recently, but then you'll have like the recent Ninja Turtles Cowabunga Collection and Shredder's Revenge. Those things came out and things are still coming out. You know, eventually I'll have to cover Marvel Rivals and I have no idea how that's going to happen, but you know, things are still coming out. And since I'm going roughly chronologically with stuff, you know, I'm looking at games in like 2006, 2007 right now. I've got Plenty of time to catch up and for them to make new games.

34:33.385 --> 34:46.824
Did you ever do— I don't know how specific you get where it has to tie back to a specific comic strip or just a general thing, like the arcade version of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Is that one that you did, the original arcade?

34:46.824 --> 34:52.486
I did, but that was also in the context of the regular Nintendo port.

34:52.486 --> 34:52.919
Okay.

34:53.303 --> 34:55.966
That makes sense. We did talk about the arcade game in there with it.

34:55.966 --> 35:01.885
That makes sense. And you're already at 2006, man. You're gonna, you're crushing through these things. How long have you been doing this now at this point?

35:01.885 --> 35:03.265
About 9, 10 years.

35:03.265 --> 35:18.248
That'll do it. Okay. Yeah. We've been at it about the same amount of time. So yeah, then you've stuck with the concept. So once you get this done and you have this and you can file this away, at what point do you know it's time to, you know, hang up your spurs and move on from it?

35:18.248 --> 35:26.028
Probably when I get to the point of holy crap, this game came out last week. I need to get an episode out.

35:26.028 --> 35:36.403
Okay. Yeah, that makes sense when it's that turnaround. Okay. Do you have, uh, have you ever had one, a game that almost broke you where you said, what am I doing? Why am I doing this with my time?

35:36.403 --> 35:45.159
No, but only because I've had guests on and I knew any game that I knew would possibly do that, I made sure to get a guest that it would be really fun to talk about it with.

35:45.159 --> 35:56.099
Okay. That makes sense. That makes perfect sense. Get that. So then where would you rank this as far as some of the adaptations you played? Is this a bottom, mid, top tier? How do you think about this one?

35:56.099 --> 36:00.368
This one doesn't do anything to turn me off of Garfield.

36:01.234 --> 36:01.347
Okay.

36:01.555 --> 36:10.397
And that kind of leans into the next question I would have for you too, is if you knew somebody who wanted to get into Garfield, would you give them this game as part of a primer course?

36:10.397 --> 37:01.103
No, not at all. This is, I think, something that would be extra credit. This would absolutely be Outside of the syllabus, not something that I would put on there for them that you could do if you want more. And again, not to beat the dead horse, but it would be dependent on the age of the person. So if they were younger and somebody that I was trying to turn my kids onto Garfield for the first time, yeah, I could see that as a part of it. If I was trying to get them playing games and they were interested in video games, and this is one that I would feel very comfortable putting my kid in front of this one for 30 minutes and letting them just go wild at it. Nothing offensive happens here. It's a good time for them. I think that this could be for the right person. If it was somebody that somehow made it to 30, 40, 50 years old and they had never seen Garfield, no, this is not what I would put in front of them. Would you? Or how would you incorporate it?

37:01.103 --> 37:43.220
That's pretty much how I land with it as well. This whole game is, we've said it a lot and we've said it because it's true, it's made for little ones. So if you're giving this to somebody that doesn't have the nostalgia factor with it, Then it's kind of wasted on them because everything is so easy. But when you have a kid looking at it, they're not going to mind all those cutscenes that bothered us so much. You know, they're not going to mind the simple game mechanics. They're not going to mind anything like that. So you get it to a kid, that's fine. And, you know, this definitely is not like an S-tier, you have to play it kind of thing. But if somebody wanted to play it, like, I wouldn't go try to convince them not to. Or anything. I just wouldn't be the person to let them know that it exists.

37:43.220 --> 37:58.630
Yeah. I mean, if I could see if I was going on a road trip, we had, you know, 10 hours and I needed to put a Nintendo DS in my 5-year-old's hand and there was a stack of games, I could throw this in the mix. Absolutely. I wouldn't have a problem with them having this one in there. Wouldn't be my go-to, but you could have it.

37:58.630 --> 38:15.474
If I was going on a road trip, I might bring it for me just because it's nice, easy. You know, I don't have to pay too much attention to it as I'm going. And if the batteries run out or we get somewhere at a bad spot and I can't save, who cares? I don't really have too much invested in the game anyway.

38:15.474 --> 38:37.908
It's a good call. It's a very good point. It is funny that it's something you bring up with the saves. They pop up so frequently and it just does have that feeling of just like, no, just continue. Just continue. It doesn't feel like I need to really save my progress at this point. So it's just the I don't know how I'm going to die, but I haven't died yet and I don't feel any real threat of dying. So I think I'm good to just continue.

38:37.908 --> 38:40.599
I'm a '90s kid. Not only do I save, I save 3 times.

38:40.599 --> 39:05.487
So I'm assuming you— this is a trauma-based response where you've had a game that you didn't save and something that you made that progress and you didn't get to the point where you could save. When you have games that specifically have to get to a certain place and you couldn't just save wherever. Do you have one that was that moment for you that you can look back on and think, okay, that broke my heart that I have to go back and do this all over again because I forgot to save?

39:05.487 --> 39:26.454
Final Fantasy VII. I can't tell you which part exactly because I've also had to restart that game so many times just because I would get caught up in life and forget what I was doing. And one of the Wii Paper Marios, we saved at a bad point. So we have a boss where we would definitely need to get the power-up that we can't get because of where the save file is.

39:26.454 --> 40:01.398
Got it. Yeah. Final Fantasy though, those games were a nightmare because it would just— they're dangerous. It's one of those things where I would just have to not have those in my house because days would disappear. That's one of those things where you started and it'd be 10 o'clock at night and you've basically set up your character, it feels like at this point and the sun's coming up. It's like you haven't done anything, but you've been completely enraptured with this. And there's what, 60 hours of gameplay in this thing if you know what you're doing. But then to actually get the mechanics of it down takes much longer for somebody like me.

40:01.398 --> 40:12.934
And finally, if we were going to switch up enough things in this game, what Muppets do you want to see Garfield interact with specifically in this world?

40:12.934 --> 40:43.359
Specifically in this world. Okay. My natural knee-jerk response without thinking this through would be Dr. Teeth. It feels like a good adversary to, to Garfield. Um, you could go with somebody that would be the positivity equivalent of an Odie, but I think you need somebody that's a little bit cynical like Garfield but has a little bit more energy. And so I could imagine that interaction. I could imagine Garfield's disgust with a character like that, and I think that would work. How about you?

40:43.359 --> 40:47.946
See, initially I jumped straight to Oscar Grouch, but they're basically the same person anyway. Sure.

40:48.170 --> 40:48.427
Yeah.

40:48.427 --> 40:53.202
Dr. Teeth though, that is amazing. He would drive Garfield crazy.

40:53.202 --> 41:04.852
That's my thought. Yeah. Either that or really anybody from that band I think would do the trick. Animal would drive him crazy. I can't remember the girl's name. The—

41:04.852 --> 41:05.461
Janis.

41:05.461 --> 41:08.474
Janis Joplin. Yeah. Is it Janis? Is that her name? Yeah, it is Janis.

41:08.522 --> 41:09.483
They made it way too obvious.

41:09.483 --> 41:24.215
Okay. Yeah, I should know that one. But yeah, anybody from that would annoy him in their own way. So I could— yeah, any of those characters would do well with it. Did you have somebody else that you would think of beyond Oscar the Grouch?

41:24.215 --> 41:31.670
Scooter, especially if he was hanging out with Odie, because both of them get really positive about things.

41:31.670 --> 41:36.527
That's very, very true. Yeah. And I could see Odie and Scooter getting along famously.

41:36.640 --> 41:41.807
Well, Chris, it has been great talking to you about all of this. If people want to hear more from you, where else can they find you around the internet?

41:41.807 --> 42:19.370
Sure. Um, I have a website. It's called Following Films. You can go to followingfilms.com. I also have a podcast, um, called Following Films. So wherever you're listening to this, if you search for Following Films, you'll find that. Um, if you enjoy this show, I've had several guests on that would probably appeal to you. Um, I've had several cast members from The Simpsons. I had a You know, Nancy Cartwright has been on, Yardley Smith has been on, the voices of Lisa and Bart. Also have had one of the comic book creators from The Simpsons on, not just Simpsons stuff, but that just seemed relevant to this audience. So if you like nerdy stuff, there's probably something there for you to check out.

42:19.370 --> 44:40.035
And as always, we'll have links to all that down in the show notes because clicking links is so much easier than trying to remember how to spell things. As always, the best place to find me is over on playcomics.com where you can find links to all the social media things. Which is pretty much Threads and Bluesky because I like to poke the bear and have fun over there and other things that rhyme with air underwear. I don't know, something like that. If you want to be a guest on the show, then there's a link on that website, which is playcomics.com, which I just said, where you can find the games that I'm looking to get booked the soonest. Those are going to be your best bet for coming on the show, especially if you like Naruto and Yu-Gi-Oh and want to come on for one of those episodes. Because there's 5 bazillion of them and there's more when I put on the next batch of things, I'm pretty sure. Oh dear God, I'm going to die. If you want to help support the show and keep me from dying, then you can be like Ono Lickglass or Dan McMahon and send the show money because unfortunately it does cost money to run a podcast. I also just saw that somebody has been using my Pinecast referral code for long enough that I get some money from that now, which is cool. So if you can start your own podcast and use my referral code, which is down in the show notes, then you can, you know, help me out that way. That's always cool. Or you can just tell your friends about it and everything, and your enemies and random people that you see on the street, and the cool bus driver that's always wearing those cool shirts. They probably want to hear about the show, so you should tell them about it. Don't forget that Play Comics is part of the gunnageek.com network, home to such other wonderful shows as Capes on the Couch, which I was just talking to Anthony yesterday, and one of the things he definitely told me, and I'm definitely not making up, is that he said he is doing a thing that he's really excited about. Also, I am not making that up because he will hear it and knows where I live. Don't forget that Play Comics is also part of the Art Comedy Pop Culture Network, home to a few other wonderful shows. And if you have a show that you think would fit in with us over there, let them know. Because again, looking for more podcasts to join up with that network. So it's a good time. You should definitely check it out. If you like the music that I'm really talking on top of right now, head on over to backingtrack.gg, check out all the great music over there, and maybe find something for your own project. But most of all, just grab a game, grab a stack of comics, and go find yourself a new favorite character.
